Cowlitz County commissioners are endorsing a U.S. Forest proposal to re-establish a primitive road to Spirit Lake, saying that protecting downstream communities from flooding is more paramount than safeguarding scientific research in the basin.

Re-establishing the road from Windy Ridge to the south shore of the lake will enable drill rigs to access the area to take core samples of the debris blockage holding back the lake. It also would make it easier to replace the aging intake gate on the 1.5-mile drainage tunnel that keeps the lake at a safe level.

The commissioners are distributing a letter, which they approved Wednesday, to local area governments seeking their endorsement. Port of Longview officials considered the letter Wednesday but are awaiting revisions to address port-specific concerns before approving it.

Citing a 1983 U.S. Geological Survey study, the letter states: “An outburst flood of the lake could generate 2.4 billion cubic yards of sediment to downstream communities, producing a catastrophic event on par with the 1980s eruption. A flood of this magnitude would likely completely inundate the port of Longview and close the ports of Portland, Vancouver and Kalama for over a month.”

The letter suggests that the Forest Service maintain the road as permanent, “not temporary.”

The road would follow the same route used in the early 1980s to build the drainage tunnel and support a temporary pumping effort. That “should limit the idea that re-establishing that route is going to dramatically impact ongoing scientific studies,” the letter says.

“While we can certainly sympathize with any impact the project may have to studies in the area, we can hardly side with those concerns over the consequences of not being able to access the lake, understand the debris blockage, and maintain long-term safe lake levels.”

The May 18, 1980, eruption of Mount St. Helens blocked Spirit Lake’s old outlet into the North Fork of the Toutle River and raised the lake about 200 feet. Without an outlet, the lake would rise, break through the debris blockage and cause unprecedented flooding in the along the Cowlitz and Toutle valleys, scientists warned. So the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers cut a drainage tunnel that opened in 1985 to control the lake level.

But the tunnel needs $5 million to $15 million in repairs, including replacement of the inlet gate that controls the flow of water into the tunnel. In addition, a panel of scientists convened by the National Academy of Sciences in 2017 recommended that the debris blockage be re-evaluated and suggested that there should be a backup system to control the lake, noting that the drainage tunnel crosses an active fault that has caused maintenance problems.

There is no emergency, but Forest Service officials hope to start replacing the tunnel inlet gate work by June 2021 and have already requested funding, said Rebecca Hoffman, manager of the Forest Service-managed.

The commissioners’ letter stresses that “the time to act is now.”

“Some past objections point out that no crisis exists today and so no action is needed. Anyone who has worked through a disaster or worked in emergency management understands that this couldn’t be farther from the truth. ... We need to be prepared before a crisis arrives,” the letter says. The Forest Service can hardly be expected to build an access road in the middle of a severe weather, volcanic, or seismic event.”

However, more than 30 research projects covering hundreds of acres on the south shore of Spirit Lake could be damaged or compromised if the Forest Service builds the road. Those projects are tracking the return of life on the mountain, and researchers are concerned that a roadway would lead to soil disturbance, pollution from equipment and possible introduction of invasive species.

The 110,000 acre Mount St. Helens National Volcanic Monument was created to preserve the land in as undisturbed a state as possible for scientific study.

In their letter, commissioners said they have “a deep appreciation for scientific research at Mount St. Helens,” but they support the road because “we feel it is our job to speak in favor of this project for the safety of our constituents living below Spirit Lake.”

Get local news delivered to your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Contact City Editor Andre Stepankowsky at 360-577-2520.


Load comments